Special Sports

World According to Me:

NFL Draft 2009:

NFC East   AFC East  
C B-
C- C
C- C-
D+ C
NFC West   AFC West  
C- C+
B C
B- D
B- B-
NFC North   AFC North  
A- B
B+ B+
B C
B A
NFC South   AFC South  
C C
B+ C-
C A
C C
 

My 2009 Draft All-Can't Miss Team:                                           My 2009 Draft All-Favorite Longshot Team:

WR

 Jeremy Maclin, Missouri, Philadelphia Eagles

 Dudley Guice, Northwestern State, Tennessee Titans
WR  Austin Collie, BYU, Indianapolis Colts  Charly Martin, West Texas A&M, San Diego Chargers
WR  Michael Crabtree, Texas Tech, San Francisco 49ers  Justin Brown, Hampton, Arizona Cardinals
TE  Jared Cook, South Carolina, Tennessee Titans  Jake O'Connell, Miami (OH), Kansas City Chiefs
TE  Brandon Pettigrew, Oklahoma State, Detroit Lions  Jerimiah Wurzbacher, No. Dakota St., SD Chargers
OT  Jason Smith, Baylor, St. Louis Rams  Sam Allen, Grand Valley State, San Diego Chargers
OT  Michael Oher, Mississippi, Baltimore Ravens  Cameron Goldberg, Duke, Baltimore Ravens
OT  Eben Britton, Arizona, Jacksonville Jaguars  Joel Bell, Furman, Buffalo Bills
OG  Andy Levitre, Oregon State, Baltimore Ravens  Roger Allen, Missouri Western, St. Louis Rams
OG  Trevor Canfield, Cincinnati, Arizona Cardinals  Ryan Durand, Syracuse, Tennessee Titans
OG  T.J. Lang, Eastern Michigan, Green Bay Packers  Lance Louis, San Diego State, Chicago Bears
OL  Max Unger, Oregon, Seattle Seahawks  Rob Bruggeman, Iowa, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
C  Alex Mack, California, Cleveland Browns  Colin Dow, Montana, Cincinnati Bengals
C  A.Q. Shipley, Penn State, Pittsburgh Steelers  Cecil Newton, Tennessee State, Jacksonville Jaguars
FB  Tony Fiammetta, Syracuse, Carolina Panthers  Marcus Mailei, Weber State, Philadelphia Eagles
FB  Frank Summers, UNLV, Pittsburgh Steelers  Tyler Roehl, North Dakota State, Seattle Seahawks
RB  Knowshon Moreno, Georgia, Denver Broncos  Rashad Jennings, Liberty, Jacksonville Jaguars
RB  Shonn Greene, Iowa, New York Jets  Tyrell Fenroy, UL-Lafayette, Chicago Bears
RB  Donald Brown, Connecticut, Indianapolis Colts  Josh Vaughan, Richmond, Tampa Bay Buccaneers
QB  Matthew Stafford, Georgia, Detroit Lions  Mike Reilly, Central Washington, Pittsburgh Steelers
QB  Mark Sanchez, USC, New York Jets  Chris Pizzotti, Harvard, New York Jets
P  Kevin Huber, Cincinnati, Cincinnati Bengals  T.J. Conley, Idaho, New York Jets
K  Graham Gano, Florida State, Baltimore Ravens  Sam Swank, Wake Forest, Philadelphia Eagles
RET  Mike Thomas, Arizona, Jacksonville Jaguars  Chris Williams, New Mexico State, Miami Dolphins
DE  Brian Orakpo, Texas, Washington Redskins  Ian Campbell, Kansas State, St. Louis Rams
DE  Lawrence Sidbury, Richmond, Atlanta Falcons  Pierre Walters, Eastern Illinois, Kansas City Chiefs
DL  Michael Johnson, Georgia Tech, Cincinnati Bengals  Clinton McDonald, Memphis, Cincinnati Bengals
DL  Evander Hood, Missouri, Pittsburgh Steelers  John Gill, Northwestern, Detroit Lions
DT  B.J. Raji, Boston College, Green Bay Packers  Jake Visser, Ferris State, Houston Texans
DT  Peria Jerry, Mississippi, Atlanta Falcons  Louis Ellis, Shaw, Miami Dolphins
LB-DE  Connor Barwin, Cincinnati, Houston Texans  Phillip Hunt, Houston, Cleveland Browns/ Nick Reed, Oregon, Seattle Seahawks
OLB  Aaron Curry, Wake Forest, Seattle Seahawks  Mike Rivera, Kansas, Chicago Bears
OLB  Jason Williams, Western Illinois, Dallas Cowboys  Dan Skuta, Grand Valley State, Cincinnati Bengals
LB  Brian Cushing, USC, Houston Texans  Brit Miller, Illinois, Carolina Panthers
ILB  James Laurinaitis, Ohio State, St. Louis Rams  Darrel Young, Villanova, Washington Redskins
ILB  Ray Maualuga, USC, Cincinnati Bengals  Daniel Holtzclaw, Eastern Michigan, Detroit Lions
CB  Malcolm Jenkins, Ohio State, New Orleans Saints  Dante Dunn, Wayne State (MI), Buffalo Bills
CB  Vontae Davis, Illinois, Miami Dolphins  D.J. Clark, Idaho State, Carolina Panthers
CB  Alphonso Smith, Wake Forest, Denver Broncos Courtney Robinson, Massaschusetts, Philadelphia Eagles
CB-S  Sherrod Martin, Troy, Carolina Panthers  Peter Ittersagen, Wheaton, Jacksonville Jaguars
S  Louis Delmas, Western Michigan, Detroit Lions  Colt Anderson, Montana, Minnesota Vikings
S  Patrick Chung, Oregon, New England Patriots  Bryan Williams, Akron, Cleveland Browns
S  Rashad Johnson, Alabama, Arizona Cardinals  Allan Nelson, McNeese State, Washington Redskins

Twelve Players who deserved a shot, but I couldn't find if they were given  a chance:

 QB Chase Clement, Rice 6-1 210, 4.60, 7.43  RB Brandon Mason, Stony Brook, 6-1 232, 4.63, 6.92
 K Andrew Wilcox, Elon, 6-2 232 (1st FCS FG/G; .846 pct)  WR Ed Gant, North Alabama, 6-2 197, 4.44, 6.77
 P Brett Arnold, Massachusetts, 6-0 185  OG Anthony Parker, Tennessee, 6-2 297, 5.08
 OG Chris Jamison, Troy, 6-2 316, 4.96, 7.73  C Adam Korby, Idaho, 6-2 294, 5.27
 DE-OLB Jameson Hartke, Ohio U., 6-4 265, 4.78  QB Jason Boltus, Hartwick, 6-3 225, 4.82, 7.00
  S Ryan Walters, Colorado, 5-11 206, 4.60, 7.01 (on a bad wheel)  SS Jim Johnson, UM-Duluth, 6-2 216, 4.63, 7.01

 

 

Dallas Cowboys: C

Team Needs:

S: (poor) Hamlin was ranked top five for strong safeties by most draft boards, but he is another big guy (6-2 214) who may not cover all that well.

WR: (poor) Manuel Johnson is injury prone and not very big or fast.  Ogletree was plagued by injuries as well, but played through them.  His 4.36 moved him up on a lot of boards.  He probably should have been drafted.

OT: (poor) Brewster is not rangy or agile enough to play tackle, may not be gritty enough to play guard.  His competition at Ball State has been questioned.  Turkovich is a gamer, but is slow with marginal athleticism.

DE: (fail) Brandon Williams was taken way too early.  Not big enough to be an every down player and not fast enough to be a 3rd down specialist.

QB: (good) McGee convinced the scouts that what he did at A&M was not indicative of his true talents.  He's big, fast and relatively nimble of body and mind. Carpenter also has decent size and feet.  He is an excellent insurance policy.

LB: (excellent) Williams, Butler and Hodge give the 'boys three of the top 20 OLBs in the draft.  Williams may be able to transition to the inside.

Other: Buehler was the top one or two kickers.  Phillips is a big, long-armed TE with decent speed and very good agility. Got both Cincy CBs?  Not sure why; both fell on boards.

Rd Pick Player Pos College
3 69 Jason Williams OLB Western Illinois Can't Miss
3 75 Robert Brewster OG-T Ball State Reach
4 101 Stephen McGee QB Texas A&M
4 110 Victor Butler OLB Oregon State
4 120 Brandon Williams DE Texas Tech
5 143 DeAngelo Smith CB Cincinnati
5 166 Michael Hamlin FS Clemson Value
5 172 David Buehler K USC
6 197 Stephen Hodge OLB TCU
6 208 John Phillips TE Virginia
7 227 Mike Mickens CB Cincinnati
7 229 Manuel Johnson WR Oklahoma Stretch

Legitimate FAs:

QB Rudy Carpenter, Arizona State

OG Greg Isdaner, West Virginia

WR Kevin Ogletree, Virginia+

OG-T Mike Turkovich, Notre Dame

OG Travis Bright, Brigham Young

 

New York Giants: C-

 

WR: (average) Nicks is a good possession receiver with excellent hands.  Barden is overrated and taken way too early, but does have size, even if he has no hops.

 

S: (excellent) Vince Anderson seemingly appeared out of nowhere to move into the top 20; has size and good speed, but is raw and level of competition is questionable. Rashad is an overachiever with good size and speed who improves the more he plays.  Goddard hits hard and often for a smaller safety and is also a ballhawk.  Romans is a solid hitter with decent speed and

instincts.

 

CB: (poor) Both Wright and Woodson fell off most boards.  Neither is big or impressive; both appear to have pesky injuries.

 

OT: (poor) Beatty slipped up boards as the likes of Andre Smith and others with question marks moved down.  He has size and athleticism, but is unpolished and is a prospect as a 2nd rounder.

 

OLB: (poor) Sintim was up and down on boards.  There were other solid LBs available. Mainor has character and drug issues, played DE in college.

 

RB: (poor) Andre Brown was a good grab in the 4th, but may not be an every down back.

 

Other: Beckum and Bomar were very good picks, excellent prospects who may not be good fits in NY and may end up playing elsewhere.  DE Alex Field came on as pass rusher, has height 6-6, could use bulk.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 29 Hakeem Nicks WR North Carolina Can't Miss
2 45 Clint Sintim OLB Virginia
2 60 Will Beatty OT Connecticut
3 85 Ramses Barden WR Cal Poly Reach
3 100 Travis Beckum TE Wisconsin
4 129 Andre Brown RB North Carolina State value
5 151 Rhett Bomar QB Sam Houston State
6 200 DeAndre Wright CB New Mexico
7 238 Stoney Woodson CB South Carolina stretch

FS Vince Anderson, Webber International

SS Trimane Goddard, North Carolina+

DE Alex Field, Virginia

SS Sha'reff Rashad, Central Florida

SS Andy Romans, Lafayette+

OLB Kenny Mainor, Troy

 

 

Philadelphia Eagles: C-

 

CB: (average) Harris may be more "macho" than proficient in coverage.  Not blessed with great speed, he tries intimidation. Courtney Robinson is a speedy cover and return man.

 

C: (average) Dallas Reynolds is a versatile center with very good size and feet who can play OG-T.

 

RB: (average) McCoy's rep took a turn for the shady.  His status was up-down all over boards.  Not big, and his willingness to run hard inside has been questioned. Thigpen is tiny, but very fast, a spot player who was team captain and can also return. Walter Mendenhall is Rashad's brother who had to transfer to Illinois State.

 

TE: (poor) Ingram is a top ten prospect coming off knee surgery. Has some size, but not astounding speed or agility.

 

WR: (excellent) Given Crabtree's injury, Maclin was the best WR in draft.  Also, returns.  Gibson was a stretch, barely in the top 50 of most boards.  Robinson is a speedy veteran player with good hops, great feet, and a penchant for big plays.

 

OG: (fail) Fanaika is very big, but not fast or fluid.  Didn't open many holes at Ariz St.

 

Other: OLB Fokou was an interesting pick, not big or strong, but athletic, twice scout team MVP, needs experience.  Reshard Langford was a top 10 SS with size and solid if unspectacular tools.  Mailei was top 20 FB, a great TE with excellent hands who must learn FB. K Sam Swank fought his way through injuries to have a solid career at Wake Forest.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 19 Jeremy Maclin WR Missouri Can't Miss
2 53 LeSean "Shady" McCoy RB Pittsburgh Reach
5 153 Cornelius Ingram TE Florida
5 157 Victor "Macho" Harris CB Virginia Tech value
5 159 Fenuki Tupou OT Oregon Stretch
6 194 Brandon Gibson WR Washington State stretch
7 213 Paul Fanaika OG Arizona State
7 230 Moise Fokou OLB Maryland

 

C Dallas Reynolds, Brigham Young+

 

RB Marcus Thigpen, Indiana+

RB Walter Mendenhall, Illinois State

ILB Josh Mauga, Nevada+ (inj. pect)

SS Reshard Langford, Vanderbilt+

FB Marcus Mailei, Weber State++ (fav longshot)

CB Courtney Robinson, Massachusetts++ (fav longshot)

K Sam Swank, Wake Forest+

WR Brandon Robinson, Boston College+

 

Washington Redskins: D+

 

OT: (fail) ??? Chris Samuels is hobbled and aging.  Jansen is past his prime and Stephon Heyer is not a quintessential starter.  Inside Randy Thomas is 33-years-old.

 

OLB: (poor) Cody Glenn is a strong, hard-working monster man, but may lack the speed and agility to play OLB, not quite imposing enough to play inside.

 

DE: (excellent) Orapko is considered soft by some, but could have been the best DE in this draft.  Derek Walker, top 20, could have been drafted, has a motor, could use some more size. Skolnitsky had a substance issue, but is an intriguing small school speciman.

 

CB: (poor) Barnes is slight, but has tremendous feet and speed.  Very smart, but must play up to his numbers.

 

ILB: (average) Henson is not big or fast, decent tackler.  Probably would have been an FA.  Darrel Young is a smaller school beast with great numbers. 

 

OG: (fail) Not a need? See above. Edwin Williams, better suited to center with bad feet and no speed, might be switched here.

 

Other: Loaded up on FB-TEs: Eddie Williams is a good one. Agnone is an overrated prospect. Frischknecht is a former WR.  Lawlor is a longshot with skills.  Hafner is purely an H-back.  Also have DT covered: Antonio Dixon has good size, speed and tools, but was injury prone. Harwell moves well for a stocky guy.  Matthews is a big, athletic sleeper.  FS Lendy Holmes is so versatile he even punted. SS Allan Nelson is a speedy tackler.  WR--Mitchell, a tall flyer with a 7th pick. Jaison Williams is still falling on draft boards.  QB Chase Daniel will be battling Colt Brennan most likely for the third string spot.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 13 Brian Orakpo DE Texas can't miss
3 80 Kevin Barnes CB Maryland value
5 158 Cody Glenn OLB Nebraska Reach
6 186 Robert Henson ILB TCU Stretch
7 221 Eddie Williams FB Idaho
7 243 Marko Mitchell WR Nevada

TE Robert Agnone, Delaware

TE Devin Frischknecht, Washington State

FS Lendy Holmes, Oklahoma+

DT Antonio Dixon, Miami+

DT Brigham Harwell, U.C.L.A.

C Edwin Williams, Maryland

QB Chase Daniel, Missouri

DE Derek Walker, Illinois+

WR Jaison Williams, Oregon

FB Dan Lawlor, Penn State+

ILB Darrel Young, Villanova++ (fav longshot)

SS Allan Nelson, McNeese State++ (fav longshot)

DT Melvin Matthews, Grambling State

DE J.D. Skolnitsky, James Madison

TE Mark Hafner, Houston

 

 

Chicago Bears: A-

 

WR: (excellent) Iglesias was an excellent choice in the 3rd. Knox was a total steal in the 5th, world class speed and proven hands, must show he can go over the middle like a Wes Welker with speed.  Kinder is good solid depth. Peterman is a quality player and leader who may make the team on special teams.

 

CB: (good) Moore was top 5 on most boards, a cover and tackler with close to top end times in all the drills. Pegues was top 5 as a FS on many boards, but he has played CB, a tad slow, stiff, but with good hops.

 

DE: (good) Gilbert may be best suited to a switch to DE with his height and quickness. Melton is a reach, but has potential. 

 

ILB: (poor) Either Freeman or Rivera, both blossoming OLBs, might backup here.

 

OG: (excellent) Louis was super value in the 7th.  A guard so athletic he will backup TE.  Lockwood is a tough, hard-nosed FCS All-American who might surprise. Conley is another very agile OG who was recruited as TE.

 

C: (poor) Possible Lockwood or Conley might step in here.

 

Other: RBs Fenroy (4-1,000 yrd rush seasons) and Lester are small, solid runners.  Al Afalava was a top 5 SS on many boards, a late bloomer whose best ball is ahead of him.  Deleston who must switch from OLB and Charbonnet are also SS with instincts and a nose for the ball.  OLBs Rivera 4.64, 6.67 at 245 and Malast were both draftable.  FB Ta'ufo'ou is nursing a knee and leg injury but won toughness awards at Cal. 

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
3 68 Jarron Gilbert DT-DE San Jose State can't miss
3 99 Juaquin Iglesias WR Oklahoma
4 105 Henry Melton DE Texas reach
4 119 D.J. Moore CB Vanderbilt Value
5 140 Johnny Knox WR Abilene Christian VALUE
5 154 Marcus Freeman OLB Ohio State
6 190 Al Afalava S Oregon State
7 246 Lance Louis OG San Diego State VALUE
7 251 Derek Kinder WR Pittsburgh stretch

OG Aaron Lockwood, S. Illinois+

OG Dennis Conley, Hampton+

OLB Mike Rivera, Kansas++

OLB Kevin Malast, Rutgers

FB Will Ta'ufo'ou, Cal-Berkeley+

SS-OLB Dahna Deleston, Connecticut

WR Eric Peterman, Northwestern++

RB Tyrell Fenroy, UL-Lafayette++ (fav longshot)

FS Daniel Charbonnet, Texas Tech+

RB Brad Lester, Auburn

CB-FS Derek Pegues, Mississippi State+

P Jake Richardson, Miami (Ohio)

P Chris Miller, Ball State+ (top 4)

 

Detroit Lions: B+

 

QB:(good) Stafford was the top QB available.  No other insurance?

 

ILB: (average) Holtzclaw took over games with double digit tackles.  Levy may see some time at ILB as well.

 

OG: (poor) Clif Ramsey may be best suited for tackle. Jonas is big, fast, and a perrenial all conference pick who could work in here. Gerberry may also be groomed here.

 

DT: (good) Hill was a top ten climber, with size, strength, and speed to play DE if needed.  Gill is a worker who won Warrior Awards, very strong and agile.

 

TE: (excellent) Pettigrew was the top TE.  Gronkowski is an excellent 7th rounder with Long arms, big hands who is smart, can block and  move the chains.

 

WR: (poor) Derrick Williams was a little reach in the 3rd, but he's a solid player with assets if not standout skills.  This one doesn't seem like it helps much.

 

Other: Delmas was the top FS.  Aaron Brown and Antone Smith are under-the-radar gems who could be breakout players.  OT Murtha could have gone higher with his immense size and awesome feet.  Kemme from Akron is almost a Murtha clone at a lesser program.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 1 Matthew Stafford QB Georgia
1 20 Brandon Pettigrew TE Oklahoma State
2 33 Louis Delmas FS Western Michigan can't miss
3 76 DeAndre Levy OLB Wisconsin stretch
3 82 Derrick Williams WR Penn State reach
4 115 Sammie Lee Hill DT Stillman (Ala.) value
6 192 Aaron Brown RB TCU
7 228 Lydon Murtha OT Nebraska VALUE
7 235 Zack Follett OLB California
7 255 Dan Gronkowski TE Maryland

 

ILB Daniel Holtzclaw, Eastern Michigan++ (fav longshot)

RB Antone Smith, Florida State+ 4.35, 6.90

OT Chris Kemme, Akron

OT Steve Jonas, Colgate++

OT-G Clif Ramsey, Boston College

C Dan Gerberry, Ball State

DT John Gill, Northwestern++

DE Ryan Kees, St. Cloud State++


K Swayze Walters, UAB+

 

 

Green Bay Packers: B

 

OLB: (good) Giving up too much for Matthews tempers his value a bit.  Brad Jones may be a good selection for the 3-4. Obiozor is a 270 lbs speedster who may play DE or OLB.

 

DE: (good) Wynn is a big game player who needs a bit more strength and size even for 3-4.  Talley has good size, but needs better feet and production. Rhyan Anderson may be the diamond in this ruff, speed, stregnth, xcllent leaps and feet.  Must focus on and of field.

 

OT: (excellent) Meredith was a steal in the 5th, a top flight tackle with speed, strength, and decent feet. Hartline played 52 games at C. Michigan, plays a little high, but has good size and savvy.  Randolph was a top 25 board prospect with strength and desire. Lang has also played OT.

 

CB: (fail) Underwood is more of a FS, may not have the coachability to switch to corner.

 

S: (poor) see above.

 

OG: (average) Lang was a very valuable 4th round pick. Lovell is a scrappy guy who can OG or C and helped opened up holes for one of the top running games in college.

 

Other: Quinn Johnson, a top 5 FB, was a good grab in the 5th.  Tyrell Sutton is a really good option for 3rd down and

is a great locker room presence.  WR Simmons, a large, fast target, and Heckendorf a speed burner with a lot of catches offer some depth at a deep position.  Butler, an ahtletic TE, left Michigan because he didn't fit the new scheme.  QB David Johnson was tremendous as a one season starter at Tulsa.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 9 B.J. Raji NT Boston College Can't miss
1 26 Clay Matthews OLB USC reach
4 109 T.J. Lang OG Eastern Michigan Value, can't miss
5 145 Quinn Johnson FB LSU
5 162 Jamon Meredith OT South Carolina Value
6 182 Jarius Wynn DE Georgia reach
6 187 Brandon Underwood FS-CB Cincinnati
7 218 Brad Jones OLB Colorado Stretch

OT Andrew Hartline, C. Michigan

OT Dane Randolph, Maryland

OG-C Lawrence Lovell, Stony Brook++ (fav longshot)

QB David Johnson, Tulsa+

DE Ron Talley, Delaware

TE Carson Butler, Michigan

TE Brandon Ledbetter, Western Michigan

WR Jamarko Simmons, W. Michigan++

RB Tyrell Sutton, Northwestern+

WR Kole Heckendorf, North Dakota State++ (fav longshot)

DE Rhyan Anderson, New Mexico State+

OLB Cyril Obiozor, Texas A&M

 

Minnesota Vikings: B

 

OT: (average) Loadholt is considered a long-term all-pro despite his bad feet, modest strength and lack of speed.  Lepori is a marginally better athlete, but never displayed tendencies to excel.

 

WR: (good) Harvin's question marks about size, attitude, and intelligence nearly obscure his obvious explosiveness on the field.  Perretta is another smaller, tougher version of Harvin with perhaps more upside in attitude and football smarts.  Winford has good size and decent speed and was twice little all-american, conference MVP, and finished wirh 247 receptions and 41 TDs.

 

C: (good) Cooper is a solid player who could use a bit more size, but is strong and agile.  Garcia is bigger, but slower, less agile, but much stronger.  Neither is Matt Birk.

 

ILB: (good) Brinkley did well to return from an ACL, has size, strength, athleticism, and if his knee holds up may be a steal in the 5th round. Francois is almost as big and even faster.  He is probably best suited outside.

 

S: (excellent) Sanford is fast, agile, and very strong, and is the all-time SEC career tackler.  Colt Anderson is a solid pick-up, strong, great leaper with good feet who was 1st team Big Sky 3 yrs. De'Von Hall is big, fast, very strong worker who climbed his way up the depth chart.

 

QB: (average) Considering Brett Favre and Sage Rosenfels might be in this mix, Sean Glennon is not a bad project with toughness and desire.

 

Other: CB Allen is rather small and might have been taken a tad early.  Holmes is a good athlete at DT who needs a bit more bulk, but is very fast.  RBs Ian Johnson (should have been drafted) and Kahlil Bell are both very talented, but most show they can stay healthy and run between the tackles. OG Kemp was a solid if unspectacular performer at Wisconsin.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 22 Percy Harvin WR Florida reach
2 54 Phil Loadholt OT Oklahoma can't miss
3 86 Asher Allen CB Georgia Reach
5 150 Jasper Brinkley ILB South Carolina Value
7 231 Jamarca Sanford SS Mississippi VALUE

DT Antoine Holmes, North Carolina State+

QB Sean Glennon, Virginia Tech

OT Bobby Lepori, Fresno State

RB Kahlil Bell, U.C.L.A.

RB Ian Johnson, Boise State++

WR Vinny Peretta, Boise State++

WR Royce Winford++

OG Andy Kemp, Wisconsin

FS Colt Anderson, Montana++ (fav longshot)

TE Nick Walker, Alabama

SS DeVon Hall, Utah State++ (fav longshot)

OLB Robert Francois, Boston College++

C Jon Cooper, Oklahoma++

OG-C Juan Garcia, Washington+

 

Atlanta Falcons: C

 

DT: (excellent) Jerry was top five on all boards, should have been #1. Walker is strong, but slow.

 

DE: (good) Sidbury was also top five, a strong, fast, active pass rusher, albeit a tad light.  Lucas is a ballplayer with just enough speed and size to let his desire pull him through.

 

OLB: (poor) Adkins is a bit of a gamble, a too small inside backer, who may not have the size or agility to play outside.  Christopher is built-like an outside backer, not strong or that agile, but is too slow to be effective outside.

 

CB: (good) Owens is very small, but will hit, and has good speed, but a definite reach taken this early.  Middleton doesn't have the size or numbers of others, but his instincts and intangibles moved him up many boards.  He was Furman Defensive MVP, led in tackles, interceptions, and even had sacks.

 

TE: (poor) The Falcons got Tony Gonzalez, but he is very short term.  They still should have drafted for the future.

 

OG: (poor) Stanchek started 48 games at LT, but his squat size and bull strength may make him a better pro OG.  Valdez is a marginally talented tackle who is probably not fast or agile enough to play OG.  Reynolds is too tall, too slow, even for OT.

 

Other: Moore is a big, tremendous athlete who can tackle and is also a ballhawk. WRs Kelly and Mougey offer tall targets who can also run. DeHaze had the second best FCS punting average and also made the 4th most FGs.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 24 Peria Jerry DT Mississippi Can't Miss
2 55 William Moore S Missouri
3 90 Chris Owens CB San Jose State Reach
4 125 Lawrence Sidbury DE Richmond Value, can't miss
5 138 William Middleton CB Furman
5 156 Garrett Reynolds OT North Carolina STRETCH
6 176 Spencer Adkins OLB Miami (Fla.) stretch
7 210 Vance Walker DT Georgia Tech

OT Jose Valdez, Arkansas

DE Marcus Lucas, Colorado+

QB John Parker Wilson, Alabama

ILB Brock Christopher, Missouri

WR Darren Mogey, S.D.S.U

OT-G Ryan Stanchek, W. Virginia+

WR Aaron Kelly, Clemson+

K-P Robbie Dehaze, Northern Arizona

 

Carolina Panthers: B+

DT: (good) Irvin is a good player who might have been available later. Marlon Favorite negotiated a very large UDFA signing bonus.  He is a strong, stocky player who must learn to excel every down to earn it.

 

CB: (excellent) Martin played CB and S at an all-conference level, even rushed the passer.  Munnerlyn, a short Darrell Green-type, was like a yo-yo on most boards.  He is fast, jumps well, and has great feet.  He may need 10 lbs of muscle to remain in the league.  Clark is much bigger, almost as fast and is a better ballhawk snaring 15 career interceptions.

 

QB: (poor) Delhomme sighed an extension, but depth is needed.  Cantwell has a lot of developing to do to be that.

 

DE: (poor) Brown is very fast, but too small to play every down.

 

WR: (average) Chery and Beavers were small college stars, but don't have the size or experience to be impact players unless it is on returns.

 

OG: (excellent) Robinson was the top guard on many boards.  His lack of great numbers dropped him, but he has shown the ability at the top level to be effective.  C.J. Davis has success at Pitt working with leverage and only decent feet.  Garry Williams was all SEC while at Kentucky.  His body type might work better at OG.  Cadogen was a top ten OT with good speed and great feet.  He was ranked the top undrafted player on most boards and Patrick Brown of C. Florida was a pre-season All-American candidate who played well, but doesn't have all the tools.

 

Other: TE Brock is inexperienced but has the size, speed, great feet and leaps to be special.  Fiammetta was the best available FB talent.  RB Goodson intrigued many, but was only a part-time player with hints he might be uncoachable.  Lee is a big, fast runner from a tiny college who might end up in CFL.  OLB Heygood was a special teams stud-depth chart climber who had over 100 tackles his senior season.  Ivy is bigger, but less athletic, may be too stiff to be effective LB.  ILB Brit Miller campaigned his name up boards until it was a surprise he wasn't drafted, reminds of a bit more gifted Spielman-type.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
2 43 Everette Brown DE Florida State reach
2 59 Sherrod Martin FS Troy
3 93 Corvey Irvin DT Georgia Reach
4 111 Mike Goodson RB Texas A&M Stretch
4 128 Tony Fiammetta FB Syracuse can't miss
5 163 Duke Robinson OG Oklahoma VALUE
7 216 Captain Munnerlyn CB South Carolina

 

TE Kevin Brock, Rutgers+

CB D.J. Clark, Idaho State++ (fav longshot)

LS Nick Sundberg, Cal-Berkeley

OT-G Garry Williams, Kentucky+

DT Marlon Favorite, Louisiana State+

FS Anthony Scirrotto, Penn State+

QB Hunter Cantwell, Louisville

RB Jamall Lee, Bishops+

OLB Anthony Heygood, Purdue+

ILB Brit Miller, Illinois, Carolina++ (fav longshot)

OT Gerald Cadogan, Penn State++

OLB Mortty Ivy, W. Virginia+

OG C.J. Davis, Pittsburgh+

OT Patrick Brown, Central Florida+

WR Jason Chery, Louisiana-Lafayette

WR Larry Beavers, Wesley

 

New Orleans Saints: C

 

CB: (good) Jenkins was the top player on most boards.  Reggie Jones is a fast, athletic former high jumper, triple jumper from a smaller program.  Gorrer is only 185 but will tackle and runs a 4.40, might be a FS.

 

S: (excellent) Vaughn is big, fast, and a definite steal in the 4th round.  See Gorrer above.

 

OLB: (good) Signed Jonathan Vilma, but he's been erratic of late.  Arnoux is a smart, fast 4 year veteran ILB who is smart enough to learn OLB.  Casillas needs to get healthy and improve his reads, but could be an excellent UFA.

 

DE: (fail) ???

 

DT: (poor) Signed Rod Coleman and Paul Spicer as FAs, but they are not impact guys by any means.

 

WR: (poor) Simon from N. Illinois and Harris from Georgia are tall, rangy college vets, but weren't difference makers on their teams.

 

Other: Morstead is a good player, but using a 5th round pick for not even the best punter in college is bad news.  RB Hill has DUI issues off the field and trouble keeping the injury bug from keeping him off the field.  However, Donaldson may be the gem of the group.  He's a strong, hard-running, good blocker team player who led the FCS in rushing. OL Fletcher and Parrish are smart, versatile guys who will try to fit in.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 14 Malcolm Jenkins CB Ohio State Can't Miss
4 116 Chip Vaughn FS Wake Forest Value
4 118 Stanley Arnoux ILB Wake Forest Reach
5 164 Thomas Morstead P SMU STRETCH

 

WR Matt Simon, Northern Illinois+

 

RB P.J. Hill, Wisconsin

RB Herb Donaldson, Western Illinois++ (fav longshot)

WR Kenneth Harris, Georgia

CB Reggie Jones, Portland State+

C Alex Fletcher, Stanford+

CB-S Danny Gorrer, Texas A&M+

OT-G Augustus Parrish, Kent State++

 

LB Jonathan Casillas, Wisconsin+

 

 

Tampa Bay Buccaneers:C

 

QB: (good) There were many diverse opinions about Freeman's worth as a 1st rounder.  That fact alone calls into question the trade-up for his selection.  Joe Ganz is a guy with unquestionable talent, but whether he can put to work for him consistently remains to be proven.  Landers could be a safety valve or a wildcat option.

 

DE: (good) Moore is a good athlete who has good intuitiveness for the ball, even broke up passes, but must bulk up or play OLB.   Buie is a legitimate DE, strong, excellent feet, but did have some acad problems.  Moffett is rush specialist.

 

CB: (poor) Biggers got picked on because of Delmas and others in the Broncos secondary.  McDuffie might be able to play corner.

 

OLB: (poor) Nathan Williams has enough speed to play OLB, might not have the size. Moffett might have enough speed to play OLB.

 

DT: (good) Miller would have been available 5th or 6th round. He is not a big guy at 310, but has decent speed for his size, decent feet, and very strong.  Duncan wa a double gap tackle at Pitt, but wasn't real active.

 

OT: (average) Fulton is a solid tackle who does have a shoulder issue, but good athletic drill times.  Bruggeman is versatile, but probably not the best option at tackle.  Darrity started 35 games and was the top HS OG in US when recruited, and excellent student who has always been a little nicked up.

 

Other: SS Byrd is a good tackler with size and 52 college games of experience.  FS Willingham is big, strong, and improving  with every game he plays. Jeffrey Jack can play either safety and is an awesome special teamer with blocked kicks and fumble recoveries.  RB Vaughn waited pateiently behind Tim Hightower, then went out and led the FCS in rushing, taking his team to the finals.  TE Hill has speed and size, played 50 college games, and won multiple HS championships at Valdosta High.  FB Jay Lucas is a tremedous athlete who can block and run the ball.  Collins is probably too small but was a RB prospect.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 17 Josh Freeman QB Kansas State
3 81 Roy Miller DT Texas REACH
4 117 Kyle Moore DE USC Reach
5 155 Xavier Fulton OT Illinois
7 217 E.J. Biggers CB Western Michigan reach
7 233 Sammie Stroughter WR Oregon State STRETCH

SS C.J. Byrd, Georgia+

DT Rashaad Duncan, Pittsburgh

RB Josh Vaughan, Richmond++ (fav longshot)

FB Conredge Collins, Pittsburgh+

FS Marshall McDuffie, Florida International+

 

OG-C Rob Bruggeman, Iowa++

QB Joe Ganz, Nebraska

OG Maurice Miller, Mississippi

OG Calvin Darrity, North Carolina+

FS DeAngelo Willingham, Tennessee+

DE Jarriett Buie, South Florida++

 

TE Cedric Hill, South Florida++

 

ILB Maurice Crum, Notre Dame+

 

P Matt Fodge, Oklahoma State+

 

ILB Nathan Williams, Murray State+
 

DE Neefy Moffett, Florida State+
 

QB-S Rodney Landers, James Madison+

 

S Jeffrey Jack, Grambling++

FB Jay Lucas - Southern Louisiana++

 

 

Arizona Cardinals: C-

 

OT: (good) Johnson is enormous, slow, with bad feet and not much strength.  He might be a guard plugger.  Pearce might be the winner here with enough size and agility to play OT.  Al-Emin fought through injuries and was a HS star at tackle, but he also might be better at OG.

 

RB: (good) If Wells can stay healthy, he's probably the most talented back in the draft.  Stephens-Howling was one of the most unexpected, bizarre uses of a draft pick in '09.

 

OLB: (good) Brown must make the transition to OLB from DE.  He has the speed, feet, and agility to do it.  Walker played both, but is more comfortable inside.

 

CB: (average) Toler became a flavor of the last couple weeks before the draft, a speedy, not overly big corner without much strength, but good feet, willingness to force sweeps and ballhawk.  Garvin is a tiny player with exceptional speed and return skills.

 

C: (poor) Canfield might be play center but is a natural guard.

 

TE: (fail) The Cards did sign FA Anthony Becht, but there are a lot of young TEs out there better.

 

Other: DE Davis is a good athlete with a lot of strength for a shade over 260.  He'll need to bulk up because his speed isn't up to OLB.  Rashad Johnson is a smart, former walk-on with good speed, feet, and cover skills who will also deliver a blow.  Justin Brown had a break out senior season as a WR, good size, strength, speed, leaps, and hands

 
Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 31 Chris "Beanie" Wells RB Ohio State
2 63 Cody Brown DE-OLB Connecticut
3 95 Julian "Rashad" Johnson S Alabama can't miss
4 131 Greg Toler CB St. Paul's (Va.)
5 167 Herman Johnson OT LSU reach
6 204 Will Davis DE Illinois stretch
7 240 LaRod Stephens-Howling RB Pittsburgh Stretch
7 254 Trevor Canfield OG Cincinnati Value, can't miss

ILB Reggie Walker, Kansas State+

OT Brandon Pearce, Memphis++

OT Khalil El-Amin, Cincinnati+

CB Michael Ray Garvin, Florida State+

WR Justin Brown, Hampton++ (fav longshot)

 

St. Louis Rams: B-

 

OT: (excellent) Smith was the best athlete available at the position and overall.  Trautwein has size and decent agility, but has a foot issue.

 

WR: (good) Foster is a very good athlete with speed, was on the '05 NC basketball champs.  Chaney has size and good football sense and was productive whenever he could get on the field at Oklahoma.  Byers is a little inexperienced but has good speed, is quite strong and eager to improve.

 

QB: (average) Null has good size and quickness, proved he was a winner who could protect the ball (48/10 TD/int ratio).  He's a project, but could surprise.

 

S: (poor) Rubins has very good size and is a good athlete having played WR and returning kicks.  Needs more work at safety. 

 

CB: (poor) Fletcher hasn't started much.  He may be better suited to play FS, but is a coachable player with good attitude, speed, and leaps.

 

OG: (average) Allen is very strong, massive, has a mean streak, and played in 48 games.  He's been battling a sports hernia. Feinga is a wide, slow, lazy player who does take up space.  Sanders is a technician at center, but may lack the physical tools to make the switch.

 

Other: ILB Laurinaitis is can't miss. DE-OLB Campbell is a smart veteran college player with great feet and non-stop hustle.  Pittman is a similar player, a bit smaller, but stronger.  DT Scott was a steal in the 4th and Newkirk was an overachieving leader at UW. FB Johnson is LB converting to FB who has won blackout awards for big hits.  Ogbonnaya is a very good prospect, a special teams stud with great hands and speed for a bigger back.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 2 Jason Smith OLT Baylor Can't Miss
2 35 James Laurinaitis ILB Ohio State can't miss
3 66 Bradley Fletcher CB Iowa reach
4 103 Dorell Scott DT Clemson Value
5 160 Brooks Foster WR North Carolina Reach
6 196 Keith Null QB West Texas A&M stretch
7 211 Chris Ogbonnaya RB Texas

WR Quentin Chaney, Oklahoma+

DT Mike Newkirk, Wisconsin+

FB Jerome Johnson, Nevada-Reno+

WR Jarrett Byers, Northeastern State++

DE Kirston Pittman, Louisiana State

SS Mark Rubin, Penn State+

OG Ray Feinga, BYU

OG Roger Allen, Missouri Western+ (fav longshot)

DE-OLB Ian Campbell, Kansas State++

OT Phil Trautwein, Florida+

C Daneil Sanders, Colorado

LB Dominic Douglas, Mississippi State

 

 

San Francisco 49ers: B

 

QB: (poor) Davis may be a good fit for the 49ers, but he dropped quickly on boards due to his poor play down the stretch and his apparent learning difficulties.  The 49ers also signed Damon Huard.

 

WR: (excellent) Crabtree was the best NCAA receiver the last two years.  If the foot heals, this will be an excellent pick.  Collins was a workhorse even at only 180 lbs.  He doesn't drop anything. 

 

S: (average) Taylor has good size, decent speed and feet, a good 7th rounder.

 

CB: (good) Lambert could have been drafted. He battled an ankle all spring, but he still showed he is speedy, has excellent feet, and is very strong for his size and uses it to force sweeps.  Word-Daniels is bigger, but almost as fast, had trouble with injuries.

 

OLB: (average) Long had the stuff to convert from DE, but a stress fracture in his foot, much like Crabtree will delay him.  Briggs is a small DE with 26 career sacks and tst team all-conference selections despite some team rules suspenions.

 

ILB: (good) McKillop should have gone much earlier.  His size, speed, strength, and smarts were tops and he was in the top ten in tackles for FBS schools.

 

Other: RB Coffee is a smart, fast, strong runner who needs carries, may have been taken a tad early.  Sheets should have been drafted, very fast, needs work breaking tackles.  TE Pascoe is big and can catch the ball, must block better and work on footwork.  DT Jean Francois was all over boards as a reputation for softness and lack of work ethic surfaced.  DE Pannel Egboh has very good size, speed, and desire to keep learning; his inexperience probably kept from being drafted--he was next after Cadogen for top undrafted players.  OT Boone fell on boards, but was twice all-big ten with height, long arms, and always a winner even back to HS.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 10 Michael Crabtree WR Texas Tech Can't Miss
3 74 Glen Coffee RB Alabama Reach
5 146 Scott McKillop ILB Pittsburgh Value
5 171 Nate Davis QB Ball State stretch
6 184 Bear Pascoe TE Fresno State
7 219 Curtis Taylor FS LSU
7 244 Ricky Jean-Francois DT LSU

 

WR Dobson Collins, Gardner-Webb++ 

DE Pannel Egboh, Stanford++

OT Alex Boone, Ohio State+

CB Terrail Lambert, Notre Dame++

CB Jahi Word-Daniels, Georgia Tech+

DE-OLB Brandon Long, Michigan State+

 

OLB Diyral Briggs, Bowling Green+

 

RB Kory Sheets, Purdue+

 

 

Seattle Seahawks: B-

 

OT: (average) Among Unger's 51 college games are several at OT where he was still all-Pac Ten.  Ramsey is big and relatively slow.  Had a good year as Ball State did.

 

RB: (good) Moore is small, fast and productive.  Roehl can play FB, but has very good speed and agility to run and catch the ball.

 

OLB: (excellent) Curry was the #1 pick who was the farthest ahead of any #2.  Philistin is fast enough to help out here, but is probably better in the middle when he wants to be?

 

QB: (poor) Teel is a big strong kid who needs technique and better feet.

 

WR: (average) Butler was a big reach.  Very slight, part-time player who can fly, but hasn't shown every down ability. Team did acquire T.J. Houshmandzadeh.

 

S: (average) Greene is strong, smart, and fast, definitely a value pick in the 7th.

 

Other: Too good not to play somewhere, Nick Reed will be tried at LB and DE.  He has great feet and closing speed on tackles, was 4th FBS sacks and 1st fumble recoveries.  DE Michael Bennett is not the biggest or fastest but has something which keeps him in a lot of plays.  DT Tez Doolittle is a similar player with more strength and quickness inside.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 4 Aaron Curry OLB Wake Forest Can't Miss
2 49 Max Unger C Oregon can't miss
3 91 Deon Butler WR Penn State REACH
6 178 Mike Teel QB Rutgers Stretch
7 245 Courtney Greene SS Rutgers Value
7 247 Nick Reed DE-LB Oregon (fav longshot)
7 248 Cameron Morrah TE California

RB Devin Moore, Wyoming+

RB Tyler Roehl, North Dakota State++ (fav longshot)

DE Michael Bennett, Texas A&M+

ILB Dave Philistin, Maryland

OT Andre Ramsey, Ball State

DT Tez Doolittle, Auburn+

 

Buffalo Bills: B-

DE: (good) Even besides his tweener size, Maybin was considered overrated by many.  He is not nimble enough to play OLB all the time. Washington is older, but has shown talent when he gets on the field.

 

OG: (good) Levitre was an excellent pick.  He was the best OG available and is versatile enough to play all OL positions. 

 

TE: (good) Nelson is very good ahtlete with great agility and speed.  If he can put on a few more pounds he could be spectacular. 

 

OT: (good) Hennessey is big and mobile with very good lateral movement.  Bell is tall, large, and strong with long arms and decent speed and agility.  He lacks experience with the game having grown up in Egypt and Croatia.

 

OLB: (good) Palmer is too light and had academic issues.  Mortenson has played both OLB-ILB. He appears fully recovered from a bad knee showing speed, hops, and excellent feet.  Harris is projected as a big SS, but was a very productive OLB.

 

DT: (poor) Faletoese is not a great athletic speciman, but has good technique getting off blocks and has a burst off the snap.

 

Other: CB talent got banked with Byrd possibly being tabbed as a S.  He had 17 interceptions and also returns.  Harris and Lankster are both gambles who may have been taken to cover the slot.  Sargeant and Dunn are more prototypical corners, both fast and small, but with very feet.  Herbert has more size and may be aimed at FS.  Davis and Godfrey are both big, fast target with good footwork and steady hands.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 11 Aaron Maybin DE Penn State Reach
1 28 Eric Wood C Louisville Big REACH
2 42 Jarius Byrd CB Oregon
2 51 Andy Levitre OG Oregon State Can't Miss
4 121 Shawn Nelson TE Southern Mississippi value
5 147 Nic Harris SS Oklahoma
6 183 Cary Harris CB USC
7 220 Ellis Lankster CB West Virginia Stretch

 

CB Lydell Sargeant, Penn State+

 

OT Nick Hennessey, Colgate++

 

DE Gerald Washington, USC

 

OT Joel Bell, Furman++ (fav longshot)

 

CB-FS Tyrrell Herbert, Toledo+

 

CB Dante Dunn, Wayne State (MI)++ (fav longshot)

 

DT John Faletoese, UC-Davis+

 

ILB-OLB Joe Mortensen, Kansas+

 

OLB Ashlee Palmer, Mississippi

 

WR Jon Davis, Azusa Pacific++

 

WR Bradon Godfrey, Utah+

 

Miami Dolphins: C

CB: (excellent) Davis has excellent speed and very quick feet.  He was falling on some boards due to a perceived bad attitude.  Smith is a tall former WR with good hands, but doesn't use his size to advantage.  He was a reach.  Clemons is a good value pick in the 5th.  He had success at both CB and S.  He'll need to focus.

 

WR: (good) Turner is a tall player who never seemed to shine at USC, but had a good Senior Bowl. Hartline also has some size, great feet, and might have been a system pick.  Chris Williams might be the diamond here.  Very small and fast (4.28) who was alos a HS high jumper, he was extremely productive and resiliant, returning kicks and catching loads of balls.

 

OG: (average) Lewis, a former DT, is solid, but unspectacular. Rogers came back from serious knee rehab to show some quicks and some skills at tackle, but may be better suited to guard.  Derenthal is a long-time center who would have to work hard to convert. Gardner is definitely an OT with his height and long arms.

 

OLB: (fail) Even if Folsom could play outside, it would be too little addition.  Team did sign Channing Crowder?

 

DT: (good) Ellis is a very strong, mean, double gapper with very fast inside moves and speed.  His level of competition has been a concern in evaluating his dominance.

 

DE: (poor) Baker has the size for DE, but not the speed.  He's a tad tall for DT.

 

Other: Pat White will be one of the most interesting stories to watch.  He may end up playing more QB than many think.  Definitely has slash possibilities.  Longshore is a big guy with past unrealized potential.  Nalbone is another great story coming out of nowhere to be a prime TE prospect, has the size to be a blocker and caught over 100 passes.  RB Kimble was in the top ten on many boards with his size, agility, and smarts, but his lack of speed and carries hurt him.  TE Bronson is a big man with decent speed and agility who caught a lot of key passes, but needs to improve blocking and heal some nagging injuries.

 
Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 25 Vontae Davis CB Illinois can't miss
2 44 Pat White QB-WR West Virginia
2 61 Sean Smith CB Utah Reach
3 87 Patrick Turner WR USC Reach
4 108 Brian Hartline WR Ohio State
5 161 John Nalbone TE Monmouth (N.J.)
5 165 Chris Clemons FS Clemson value
6 181 Andrew Gardner OT Georgia Tech
7 214 J.D. Folsom ILB Weber State Big Stretch

 

C Alex Derenthal, Temple+

 

RB Anthony Kimble, Stanford+

OT-G SirVincent Rogers, Houston+

TE Jared Bronson, Central Washington++

OG Mark Lewis, Oregon

DE-DT Ryan Baker, Purdue

WR Chris Williams, New Mexico State++ (fav longshot)

 

QB Nate Longshore, Cal-Berkeley

 

DT Louis Ellis, Shaw++  (fav longshot)

 

 

New England Patriots: C-

 

ILB: (poor) Appleby is a big, rangy guy who could use some work on his feet.

 

OLB: (average) McKenzie was a good value in the 3rd.  A strong hitter with decent speed and good feet and athleticism.

 

S: (excellent) Chung was the top SS on most all boards.  McClinton has good size, speed and will hit, but is a bit unagile.

 

RB: (fail) Not the greatest class of runners, but plenty decent ones to try out.

 

TE: (fail) Much better class of TEs, but see above.

 

QB: (average) Not real big, but quite agile, Hoyer has some potential, but it didn't shine through a lot in college.  Edelman is most likely a slash or a DB-WR than a QB.

 

Other: DT Brace needs to stay healthy but should be a solid run stopper.  Pryor is very squat, but active.  Richard is not strong or quick or agile, but plays hard, could surprise. CB Butler is slight and shy, nursing a bad knee, but is fast. Jamar Love may be the surprisingly good pick-up, faster and bigger than Butler. OT Vollmer is an intriguing foreign born player with tremendous size and future upside the more he learns.  Bussey is a former walk-on with a work ethic who may be better at OG.  Ohrenberger is an OG known for overcoming his lack of size and natural abilities with a dogged mean determination.  WR Tate was taken way too early, very slight with a bad knee.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
2 34 Patrick Chung SS Oregon Can't Miss
2 40 Ron Brace DT Boston College reach
2 41 Darius Butler CB Connecticut Reach
2 58 Sebastian Vollmer OT Houston
3 83 Brandon Tate WR North Carolina
3 97 Tyrone McKenzie OLB South Florida value
4 123 Rich Ohrnberger OG Penn State reach
5 170 George Bussey OT Louisville
6 198 Jake Ingram LS Hawaii
6 207 Myron Pryor DT Kentucky
7 232 Julian Edelman QB Kent State
7 234 Darryl Richard DT Georgia Tech stretch

 

OL Jermail Porter, Kent State (K.S.U. Wrestler/Try-out)

QB Brian Hoyer, Michigan State+

ILB Antonio Appleby, Virginia+

SS Marcus McClinton, Kentucky+

CB Jamar Love, Arkansas++ (fav longshot)

 

P Aaron Perez, UCLA+

 

New York Jets: C

QB: (average) Even if Sanchez becomes a very good QB, there is no way his performance can make up for the loss of a 1st and 2nd round pick (it's a fair bet that Alex Mack and David Veikune may be more valuable by themselves) and three NFL players.  Grabbing up Chris Pizzotti, a big, smart, athletic project was a good insurance move.

 

S: (average) Cook is not big or fast and refused to run cones.  Fitzhugh has more athleticism, but his commitment has been questioned.

 

WR: (fail) Davis has some size and decent hands but wasn't a big time contributor.

 

DE: (good) Potter should have been drafted.  He's tall, fast, smart, and has excellent feet.  Westerman is small but very strong and athletic with great feet and toughness.  He performed all the drills with a torn bicep.  Steinkuhler is fast enough for DE, not quite bulky for DT.

 

FB: (good) Southerland has decent size and speed.  Toal is a LB trying to convert.  A talented athlete, he was a tad injury prone.

 

TE: (good) Davie and Myers were both considered draftable.  Davie is big and can block.  Myers is more of an H-back.  The Jets are high on the basketballer Bullock turning himself into an Antonio Gates.

 

Other: RB Greene was an opportune pick as several teams were ready to take him.  OG-T Slauson is enormous with fair athleticism who was a stretch as a draft pick. OT McKee is tall, large, and extrmely agile, but is favoring a shoulder. Link is former TE who has been slowed drastically by a bad knee.  C Parenton is a solid veteran with modest size and abilities. P Conley is a big boomer who led FBS in punt average.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 5 Mark Sanchez QB USC can't miss
3 65 Shonn Greene RB Iowa Can't Miss, value
6 193 Matt Slauson OG Nebraska Stretch

 

SS Keith Fitzhugh, Mississippi State

C Michael Parenton, Tulane

SS Emanuel Cook, South Carolina

FB Brannan Southerland, Georgia++

OT Ryan McKee, Southern Mississippi+

OT Kyle Link, McNeese State

QB Chris Pizzotti, Harvard++ (fav longshot)

TE J'Nathan Bullock, Cleveland State (Basketball Player)

TE Andrew Davie, Arkansas+

P T.J. Conley, Idaho+

TE Robert Myers, Utah State+

DE Zach Potter, Nebraska++

DE Jamaal Westerman, Rutgers++

DT-DE TY Steinkuhler, Nebraska+

WR Britt Davis, Northern Illinois

LB-FB Brian Toal, Boston College

 

Baltimore Ravens: B

 

WR: (good) With his size and speed (6-3 and 4.29), Riley pushed his way up many charts, especially after catching passes from the basketball guard Paulus.  Most likely remained undrafted because of amger management issues.  Williams is big and fast and was near the top of some boards before he fell rapidly when other better, more productive athletes emerged.

 

DE: (good) Kruger is not particularly big or strong.  He has fairly good agility, but was taken way too early.  Van DeSteeg is a small, very active DE who may not be able to pack on enough weight to be a full-time contributor.  Johnson may be able to play DE if he can add some speed to his amazing strength (47 reps).

 

ILB: (good) Phillips is a smart, fast player who must overcome a nagging knee, a great value if he stays healthy.  Ellerbe's fall off the draft list was one of the mysteries of the two-day event.  He is top five for prospects not taken.  Word was he was hiding an injury.

 

CB: (poor) Webb is tiny from a small college program who had character flags.  He does have primo speed and agility, but his stepping up to NFL level is in doubt.  Jones is also small with a bit more beef, but not as much natural ability.

 

OLB: (fail) Ellerbe may be able to play here some. As always the draft was deep here.

 

OT: (excellent) There was some disagreement about whether Oher was the best or 3rd or 4th best OT in the draft.  No disagreement about whether he had tremendous talent.  Goldberg could use some bulk, but his strength was near the tops in the draft and his speed and footwork are very good for a man his size.  Ryan was a team captain and a fixture at LT four out of five years and made all-conference twice.

 

Other: TE Drew may have been available after the draft. He's got good size and speed, but his skills were a question mark.  RB Peerman was slated to go much higher because of his size, speed, strength and decent feet.  FB Cook is a stocky guy who can block, but also ran the ball well.  QB Drew Willy slipped through the draft when he was expected to be a 6th or 7th pick be some team because of his size, speed, and excellent feet. K Gano has a big leg and was considered top three.

 
Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 23 Michael Oher OT Mississippi Can't Miss
2 57 Paul Kruger DE Utah Reach
3 88 Lardarius Webb CB Nicholls State (La.) Stretch
5 137 Jason Phillips ILB TCU value
5 149 Davon Drew TE East Carolina
6 185 Cedric Peerman RB Virginia Value

CB David Jones, Kentucky

FB Jason Cook, Ole Miss+

WR Isaiah Williams, Maryland

K Graham Gano, Florida State++ (can't miss)

ILB Dannell Ellerbe, Georgia++

OT Greg Ryan, Western Kentucky++

QB Drew Willy, Buffalo++

DT-DE Will Johnson, Michigan++

DE Willie VanDeSteeg, Minnesota+

WR Eron Riley, Duke+

 

OT Cameron Goldberg, Duke++ (fav longshot)

 

 

Cincinnati Bengals: B+

 

ILB: (good) Maualuga is a very good pick and an excellent value in the 2nd round.  He can team with Rivers for a USC tandem.  

 

C: (average) Luigs dropped on a lot of boards, but he's a past Rimington winner who can run block and has enough athleticism to master protection schemes.

 

OT: (good) Smith is a powder keg.  His stock was already dropping when he lost his grip.  Norell is a big agile guy with good speed  who was a steady player. Sutter is a big guy who started 33 games switching from left to right tackle to protect the back side of his QBs.  Dow is a solid center, but may be versatile enough to contribute somewhere across the off. line.

 

DE: (good) Johnson is a former TE with height, speed, strength, leaps, and decent footwork.  He could use a bit more bulk and a mean streak. Skuta will most likely be used as an OLB.  Aside from size, he put up awesome numbers.  McDonald is a great athlete, but most likely remains at DT if he can add the bulk.

 

S: (good) Nelson is a former option QB with excellent speed and does not shy away from contact.  Gathof is a top tackler with good size and also returns kicks, named 1st team all-conf twice.

 

QB: (average) Boeckman rose up the charts a second time as his attributes compared better, size, speed, feet.  Farris split time in college, but also has size and some flash.

 

Other: TE Coffman was a reach and still must heal.  Mooney is a good player without the size to play TE or even H-back. WR Brown is a big, agile guy. Cosby has been compared to Eddie Royal, but has attitude issues.  Orton is a big, fast solid receiver who makes clutch catches.  CB Trent is the best value pick of the draft, a top five guy with size and speed who has intercepted over 30 passes in colllege and HS.  Rico Murray has the speed, leaps, and shiftiness to be a great special teams and nickel DB.  RB Scott has  baggage including fisticuffs with coaches, but did win the Harlon Hill and the div 2 championship. Lucky, Vakapuna, and Pressley are excellent ball carriers for big men.  Huber was the top-rated punter in the draft.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 6 Andre Smith OT Alabama
2 38 Rey Maualuga ILB USC Value, can't miss
3 70 Michael Johnson DE Georgia Tech can't miss
3 98 Chase Coffman TE Missouri reach
4 106 Jonathan Luigs C Arkansas reach
5 142 Kevin Huber P Cincinnati Can't Miss
6 179 Morgan Trent CB Michigan VALUE
6 209 Bernard Scott RB Abilene Christian
7 215 Fui Vakapuna RB Brigham Young
7 249 Clinton McDonald DT Memphis
7 252 Freddie Brown WR Utah

QB Todd Boeckman, Ohio State++

OG-C Colin Dow, Montana++ (fav longshot)

CB Rico Murray, Kent State++ (fav longshot)

OLB Dan Skuta, Grand Valley State++

RB Marlon Lucky, Nebraska

FB Chris Pressley, Wisconsin+

FS Tom Nelson, Illinois State+

WR Quan Cosby, Texas+

WR Greg Orton, Purdue+

 

QB Billy Farris, Colorado State

 

S Brandon Gathof, Eastern Kentucky+

 

TE-FB Andrew Mooney, Ohio+

 

OT Steve Sutter, Miami of Ohio+

 

OT Ray Norell, Buffalo++

 

 

 Cleveland Browns: C

 

OLB: (good) Maiava was considered by some to be the best of the USC backers, but he looks more like a SS. As does Venson.  Foster looks the part at 6-4 and 245, but most show cover and other NFL skills. Veikune might make the switch, but he is such a good end; he seems more effective as a Dwight Freeney-type.  Hunt, another small DE, might be able to make the transition here or to ILB.  He has a 41 inch leap, fantastic feet, and led the FCS in sacks.

 

CB: (excellent) Carey was a shut down corner at Norfolk, has the size and speed to be effective if he continues to develop.  Francies was higher than a 6th rounder on a lot of boards. He got shuttled around to three different colleges, is a little slight and not that fast, but had still managed to amass quite a few interceptions.  Hyland might be a small college super find with decent size, good speed, hops, and feet, had 21 int. while being named all conf. three years.  Smith is a small, solid athlete who posted some of the top agility times.

 

S: (good) Ness came on late and turned in a 6.64 cone drill.  He has good size and speed and is quite strong.  He will only get better.  Williams has under 4.4 speed, was a former RB-WR with excellent feet, leaps, and drive.

 

WR: (good) Robiskie might have been a little reach, but he has the smarts and skills.  Massaquoi was definitely a reach.  Needs to display some toughness, willingness to learn, and work ethic.  Norwood is a lithe athlete, but way too slight at 170. 

 

RB: (poor) Davis has not shown great speed, strength or cuts.

 

TE: (fail) Brouse is big enough, but not fast or overly talented.

 

Other: C Mack is a good, smart player, but taken way too early.  No one plummetted down the charts like QB Graham Harrell, but it looks as though the Browns are interested.  Hard not to be interested when you look at what he did the last two years.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 21 Alex Mack C California can't miss
2 36 Brian Robiskie WR Ohio State
2 50 Mohamed Massaquoi WR Georgia Reach
2 52 David Veikune DE-OLB Hawaii can't miss
4 104 Kaluka Maiava OLB USC
6 177 Don Carey CB Norfolk State
6 191 Coye Francies CB San Jose State Value
6 195 James Davis RB Clemson Stretch

 

TE Steve Brouse, Connecticut

FS Nate Ness, Arizona++

SS Bryan Williams, Akron++

SS-LB Jason Venson, Central Florida

WR Jordan Norwood, Penn State

QB Graham Harrel, Texas Tech+

CB David Hyland, Morehead State++ (fav longshot)

OLB Jonathan Foster, Central State (OH)+

OLB Phillip Hunt, Houston++ (fav longshot)

CB Antonio Smith, Bowling Green+

 

 

Pittsburgh Steelers: A

 

CB: (good) Lewis has good size, speed and strength, may be a bit stiff.  Burnett is a smaller, more agile guy who can also return kicks.

 

OG: (good) Urbik uses technique and strength to make up for a relative lack of physical gifts.  Foster is huge and wide with decent feet, a tad slow.

 

C: (good) Getting Shipley in the 7th was one of the best value picks in the draft. The ’08 Rimington winner is incredibly strong with great feet and scored a 40 on the Wonderlic. 

 

ILB: (good) Korte is a small school stud, built like Zach Thomas, he has speed, hops and agility making 1st team all-conf multiple years.  Schantz is a bit bigger if a tad less agile, but with no less beacon for the ball.

 

DE: (average) Hood will most likely move his active motor to DE. 

 

FB: (excellent) Summers is known as "The Tank," with good speed and decent feet, he can block and run the ball, benches around 500.  Redman has FB size with tailback numbers.  Johnson might be a great TE with some height.  He'll learn FB and be productive like past Arkansas State FB Oren O'Neal.

 

Other:  WR Wallace may have been a little reach, but he has size, deep threat speed, and excellent leaps.  Grisham is probably too small to be a pro, but he's a willing blocker and a good special teams asset.  SS Richardson has decent speed and strength and feet, but turned that into 1st FBS tackles ’08.  Estermyer was considered by many the only LS worth a draft pick. QB Reilly has size and arm and built an impressive small school career and was listed by many as the top signal caller not drafted.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 32 Evander "Ziggy" Hood DE-DT Missouri  can't miss
3 79 Kraig Urbik OG Wisconsin
3 84 Mike Wallace WR Mississippi
3 96 Keenan Lewis CB Oregon State
5 168 Joe Burnett CB Central Florida
5 169 Frank Summers FB UNLV value, can't miss
6 205 Ra'Shon "Sonny" Harris DT Oregon stretch
7 226 A.Q. Shipley C Penn State VALUE, can't miss
7 241 David Johnson FB-TE Arkansas State value

FB Isaac Redman, Bowie State

SS Derrick Richardson, New Mexico State

WR Tyler Grisham, Clemson

ILB Tom Korte, Hillsdale++ (fav longshot)

LS Mark Estermyer, Pitt+

QB Mike Reilly, Central Washington, Pittsburgh++ (fav longshot)

OT Ramon Foster, Tennessee

 

ILB Andy Schantz, Portland State++

 

 

Houston Texans: C

 

DT: (good) Leonard is a solid DT with excellent strength (41 reps) and agility.  Visser was a small school terror with inside sack speed and blocked four kicks, but needs bulk and strength.

 

OLB: (excellent) Cushing and Barwin should be immediate impact players who can run down backs and rush the passer.  Verdell also has good speed and talent.

 

RB: (average) Foster is injury prone and not gifted with high end speed, but is big and elusive when healthy.  Johnson is a strong, stocky workhorse who also fights injuries, finished in top ten FCS yards/G.

 

S: (poor) Nolan is a big play guy who needs more experience.  He's not fast or strong despite good size and is also injury prone.

   

WR: (poor) Jones is 6-4 and fast, but is a Yankee prospect as well.  Casey is another former baseball player and QB who the Texans may be hoping can split out even at 235 lbs.  He has good if not great speed and may not be a TE.

 

DE: (average) Jamison is slow, not strong or agile, but is tough and aggressive enough to shut down his end.  Barwin may put his hand down eventually.

 

Other: CB-S Quin is a good sized ballhawk with speed who must step up.  McCain is small, but rose up draft charts with his agility and leaping ability.  OG-C Caldwell may be a good back-up with his versatility.  Helms is gritty, but not athletic.  OG Walker has shown potential when he finds the desire.  OT Dedrick is a veteran player with good leaps, decent agility, and has some technical skills, might end up at OG. Watkins is an enormous, slow lumberer who is hard to get around. 

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 15 Brian Cushing OLB USC can't miss
2 46 Connor Barwin DE-OLB Cincinnati Can't Miss
3 77 Antoine Caldwell OG-C Alabama Reach
4 112 Glover Quin CB-S New Mexico
4 122 Anthony Hill TE North Carolina State REACH
5 152 James Casey TE Rice value
6 188 Brice McCain CB Utah
7 223 Troy Nolan S Arizona State stretch

C Brett Helms, Louisiana State

WR Michael Jones, Arizona State+

DT Jake Visser, Ferris State++ (fav longshot)

OLB Toddrick Verdell, Florida State

OG Brandon Walker, Oklahoma+

DT Josh Leonard, Hawaii++

OT Doug Dedrick, Iowa State+

OT Jason Watkins, Florida

RB Arian Foster, Tennessee

DE Tim Jamison, Michigan

 

RB Jeremiah Johnson, Oregon

 

 

Indianapolis Colts: C-

 

DT: (excellent) Moala didn't have his best year, but he has still has the potential.  Taylor is a strong, squat, NT-type with good enough feet to be a two-gapper. Kuntz shined late in the season as he gained confidence.  He needs some bulk, but is very nimble and tricky.  Grady is a similar player even stronger with good speed, feet, and technique.

 

CB: (poor) Powers is a tad short, but is strong and agile with good speed, a good hitter who's fought through nagging injuries. 

 

C: (poor) Lewis is a decent athlete, very strong and very versatile, has played all OL positions.  Thomas is a fat man who moves his girth well, a decent OG may not be a C.

 

ILB: (fail) ???

 

S: (fail) ???

 

WR: (good) Collie has decent size and is very strong with good speed and excellent hands, runs precise patterns, was 3rd FBS Rec/G and 1st rec yds ‘08.  Matthews was a possession receiver with good enough speed to get deep, led the FCS in rec yards/g and had 50 TDs and close to 200 catches for his career.

 

Other: QB Painter has as much upside through system and ability to play in pro offenses.  RB Brown is a solid player, worker and citizen, made lots of carries look like a light load.  P-K McAfee was 17/20 FGs, hit 52 ydr, 2/2 +50 and was 8th FBS avg punt.  They also brought in P Masthay so maybe McAfee will place kick if Vinatieri ages badly.  Cloherty must learn FB, but has good size, speed and strength, is already a good blocker with great feet. Pestock is a 6-7 300 guard who can also play OT.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 27 Donald Brown RB Connecticut can't miss
2 56 Fili Moala DT USC
3 92 Jerraud Powers CB Auburn Reach
4 127 Austin Collie WR Brigham Young VALUE, can't miss
4 136 Terrance Taylor DT Michigan
6 201 Curtis Painter QB Purdue
7 222 Pat McAfee P-K West Virginia
7 236 Jaimie Thomas OG Maryland Stretch

FB Colin Cloherty, Brown, Indianapolis++

OT Tom Pestock, Northwest Missouri++

WR John Matthews, San Diego++ (fav longshot)

DT Pat Kuntz, Notre Dame+

OLB Tyrell Sales, Penn State

OT-OG Cornelius Lewis, Tennessee State++

DT Adrian Grady, Louisville+

P Tim Masthay, Kentucky

 

Jacksonville Jaguars: A

WR: (excellent) Thomas was a fine 4th round pick.  A guy who can be a possession receiver, a deep threat, and return kicks.  He reminds of the Jags' Steve Smith.  Dillard is a bit bigger but much the same sort of all-around player, perhaps even a better receiver.  Underwood is a former triple jumper who has even better agility as the tiny duo, but has even more agility.

 

OT: (excellent) Britton is the OT left out, the one with the chip on his shoulder because of it.  A smart, feisty, giant who lets no one cross his ground.  Monroe is a sham in comparison, but many evaluators still believe he has the makings of a great OT.  What a pair of bookends to run and pass behind.

 

ILB: (poor) Russell or Allen might be able to play inside, but are very adept at OLB. Williams, a DE, is big and strong enough to play inside with very good feet, leaps, and athleticism.

 

DT: (good) Knighton was not consider enough of a junkyard dog to be a top choice.  The Jags liked his athletic speed and intelligence.  He needs to heal a bad wrist.  Hypolite got double-teamed all year, a smart, strong, stocky guy with very good feet who never gave in.  Abdallah was a part-timer who played some DE, was unstoppable in workouts, 6-4 292, inexperienced, but still learning.

 

RB: (excellent) Jennings was an amazing pick in the 7th. Legitimately was probably the 3rd best back in the draft. Strong, athletic with good hands, speed, feet, and hops, was 5th FCS rushing.  Bolen is a good enough runner to be a tailback, but a good enough blocker with enough size to be a FB.  Bell is a similar combination, maybe even a better runner as he is the HS rushing for the state of CO.

 

OG: (poor) Newton is versatile enough to pay some OG, but is a very good center.

 

Other: CB Cox was taken too early.  He may be better as an FS.  Ittersagen was Defensive Player of the Year, a whale of a tackler and is also adept at returns.  Lewis is a former track man (4.34) who's inexperienced, but improving.  TE Miller is an athlete who was an outstanding running-throwing QB who will be asked to play TE.  Lorenzen is being asked to try the same thing.  QB Brown may be asked to slash.  Desormeaux may play end up playing S, but has ## for QB.  DE Jeremy Navarre is very strong, has good feet, played some DT.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 8 Eugene Monroe OT Virginia
2 39 Eben Britton OT Arizona Can't Miss
3 72 Terrance Knighton DT Temple
3 73 Derek Cox CB William & Mary Reach
4 107 Mike Thomas WR Arizona VALUE, can't miss
5 144 Jarett Dillard WR Rice VALUE
6 180 Zach Miller TE Nebraska-Omaha stretch
7 250 Rashad Jennings RB Liberty Value, (fav longshot)
7 253 Tiquan Underwood WR Rutgers VALUE

 

CB DeWayne Lewis, Southern Utah

OLB Johnny Williams, Kentucky

FB-RB Brock Bolen, Louisville++

OLB Russell Allen, S.D.S.U.+

CB-S Peter Ittersagen, Wheaton++ (fav longshot)

QB Michael Desormeaux, Louisiana-Lafayette++

RB Kyle Bell, Colorado State++

QB Nathan Brown, Central Arkansas+

QB-TE Tyler Lorenzen, Connecticut

DE-OLB Julius Williams, Connecticut++

DT George Hypolite, Colorado++

DT-DE Nader Abdullah, Ohio State+

DE Jeremy Navarre, Maryland+

 

C Cecil Newton, Tennessee State++ (fav longshot)

 

 

Tennessee Titans: C

 

DT: (good) Marks fell on boards, but still has the makings of an excellent DT if he puts it all together.  Many believe King will exceed Marks, but one of the two or both will be very good.

 

CB: (good) Mouton was a big reach, too short, but very good drill numbers may not translate to NFL.  McCourty also had good numbers, very speedy, great feet, good hops, decent strength, but needs better hands and agressiveness. Haynes is short, small, but has decent speed, instincts, and will hit.

 

OLB: (average) McRath is a smart, speedy tackler who may be best suited for OLB.  With good agility, he was 10th FBS tackles. 

 

DE: (poor) King might get switched outside.

 

WR: (good) Britt was a reach at number one. He has size and some speed for size with strength, but is not a game changer.  Edison played a lot of games, has speed, good leaps and feet, but is not strong or substantial.  Guice, almost as big as Britt, is the ace in the hole with excellent speed, leaps, agility, and is also an excellent student and worker.

 

C: (poor) Ryan Schmidt is very big and most likely locked in at guard.  Durand is also an OG who was an absolute steal in the 7th round.

 

Other: Cook was the best athlete available at TE.  OT Kropog, a veteran college player, with pretty good feet was taken too early.  RB Ringer could be a steal in the 5th, doesn't have size, but has shown the productivity when given the ball.  Ferguson is a physical runner who is almost big enough to be a FB.  Schommer is a flyer at S, a guy who can help out on special teams and develop into a solid fifth back.

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 30 Kenny Britt WR Rutgers reach
2 62 Sen'Derrick Marks DT Auburn Reach
3 89 Jared Cook TE South Carolina can't miss
3 94 Ryan Mouton CB Hawaii REACH
4 130 Gerald McRath ILB Southern Mississippi Value
4 135 Troy Kropog OT Tulane  
5 173 Javon Ringer RB Michigan State VALUE
6 203 Jason McCourty CB Rutgers
6 206 Dominique Edison WR Stephen F. Austin stretch
7 239 Ryan Durand OG Syracuse VALUE, (fav longshot)
7 242 Nick Schommer FS North Dakota State

CB Jeremy Haynes, McNeese State

OG Ryan Schmidt, South Florida

RB Rodney Ferguson, New Mexico+

WR Dudley Guice, Northwestern State++ (fav longshot)

 

DE-DT Mitch King, Iowa++

 

 

Denver Broncos: C+

 

QB: (poor) Brandstater has the best size and agility of any QB in the draft, but needs to raise his game for the NFL level.  Kyle Orton must be good enough.

 

DE: (good) Ayers, who is overrated as either a DE or OLB, will likely end up playing here.  Davis has good size, decent speed, but is already older than the others.  Kelley led Kentucky in tackles from DE his senior year.

 

OLB: (poor) Robinson has good size and speed, but is not very agile.  Didn't overpower the lower college level competition.

 

NT: (good) Baker has good speed for his substantial size, good lateral moves and pass rush.  Pedescleaux is 305, but may try DE given his pass rushing skills.  He is not the quintessential NT.

 

CB: (good) Smith is short, but solid, and has speed and anticipation.  He can be burned but was 3rd FBS interceptions.  Johnson fell down most boards when his weaknesses emerged both on and off the field. McBath played corner but will probably be a FS. He doesn't shy from contact, is smart and has good speed, great feet, and is strong despite being a little light. He was tied for 3rd FBS interceptions.  Bruton is also an FS built more like a LB, yet is still speedy with excellent leaps, smarts, good agility and good tackler.

 

RB: (excellent) Moreno was the best choice available. Can you build a new regime on him?

 

Other: TE Quinn is an excellent blocker.  Branson is too small to be a TE, but may be an H-back or make the transition to FB.  OG Olsen can also play OT, has good size and excellent feet, a bulldog in the trenches. C Schlueter was the most athletic center in the draft.  He can do it all, even pulling.  WR McKinley's great numbers don't translate to production, may have been a stretch.  Swift is a talented versatile guy who has played QB, RB, and WR.  OT Stanley Bryant won leadership awards and played LT for three years, needs a bit more bulk, but could be good depth. 

 
Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 12 Knowshon Moreno RB Georgia Can't Miss
1 18 Robert Ayers DE-OLB Tennessee REACH
2 37 Alphonso Smith CB Wake Forest can't miss
2 48 Darcel McBath FS Texas Tech
2 64 Richard Quinn TE North Carolina Reach
4 114 David Bruton FS Notre Dame
4 132 Seth Olsen OG Iowa
5 141 Kenny McKinley WR South Carolina Stretch
6 174 Tom Brandstater QB Fresno State
7 225 Blake Schlueter C TCU Value

TE-FB Marquez Branson, Central Arkansas+

CB Dominque J. Johnson, Jackson State+

DE Rulon Davis, Cal-Berkeley

WR Nate Swift, Nebraska

DT Chris Baker, Hampton+

OT Stanley Bryant, E. Carolina

OLB Lee Robinson, Alcorn State+

DT Everette Pedescleaux, N. Iowa++

 

DE Braxton Kelley, Kentucky+

 

 

Kansas City Chiefs: C

 

CB: (average) Washington started 32 games frosh-junior years.  He has great leaping ability, good feet and speed, could use more strength.

 

RB: (average) Williams is a compact, strong runner with speed and smarts, could use some more agility.

 

DE: (excellent) Jackson is a bit overrated, probably taken too early, but will likely develop into a steady player if not an all-pro. Magee was a DT, but has good enough speed and agility numbers to play outside. Walters should have been drafted, a very skilled, speedy player who needs a little more bulk.  Greenwood was a a part-time player with good size who worked himself into a specialist pass rusher role.

 

OLB: (good) Smith has played has great agility, leaps, and inuition, extremely versatile, he's played ILB-OLB-SS.  Belcher is a small DE who must learn OLB.  He had decent speed and great feet, may end up playing ILB.

 

WR: (poor) Lawrence moved up some boards, but was probably a stretch as a draft pick.  He's athletic, vry speedy and strong for his slight weight with good hands, but will be tested in the big league. 

OG: (fail) OT Colin Brown is huge, slow, but expansive, and aint playing no guard.

 

Other: TE O'Connell might switch to FB, but as former WR with a 41 in. leap and astounding agility for a guy his size, he might stay at TE.  K Succop, Mr. Irrelevent, was one of the few kickers chosen with a pick.  SS Price has size and packs a wallop as well as an ability to defend. 

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 3 Tyson Jackson DE LSU
3 67 Alex Magee DT Purdue
4 102 Donald Washington CB Ohio State can't miss
5 139 Colin Brown OT Missouri REACH
6 175 Quinten Lawrence WR McNeese State Stretch
7 212 Javarris Williams RB Tennessee State value
7 237 Jake O'Connell TE Miami (Ohio)
7 256 Ryan Succop K South Carolina

 

SS Ricky Price, Oklahoma State+

DE Bobby Greenwood, Alabama

DE Pierre Walters, Eastern Illinois++ (fav longshot)

ILB Jovan Belcher, Maine++

 

LB Bobby Abare, Yale

 

OLB Corey Smith, Cincinnati+

 

 

Oakland Raiders: D

 

WR: (good) Heyward-Bay is extremely fast and taken extremely early for his scouting report.  Murphy, in contrast, was a very good value and may turn out to be a gem.

 

C: (poor) OG Compas has speed, decent size and strength and has played some center.

 

DT: (fail)

 

OLB: (average) Norris is a small DE who will learn to play OLB and will be a special teams stalwart.

 

S: (good) Mitchell's pick drew hoots, but he was moving up many boards as a SS carrying 220 with 4.45 speed and great leaping ability, it was not such an outlandish pick.  Much of the upset was from scouting directors for other teams who wanted the guy in the 4th or 5th round. 

 

DE: (good) Shaughnessy had his moments in an injury prone career at UW. Sulak has the speed to be a monster OLB, but his size and strength make him a good rush end who was 5th in forced fumbles for FBS.  Bryant is a big strong force who needs better footwork to be effective at pro level.

 

Other: TE Myers was a stretch as a draft pick with better players available.  ILB Frantz Joseph is a smaller school legend who should have been drafted.  He overachieves so much he gets in on almost every tackle, can't be judged by numbers but by heart. 

 

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 7 Darrius Heyward-Bey WR Maryland reach
2 47 Mike Mitchell S Ohio can't miss
3 71 Matt Shaughnessy DE Wisconsin Reach
4 124 Louis Murphy WR Florida Value
4 126 Slade Norris OLB Oregon State
6 199 Stryker Sulak DE Missouri
6 202 Brandon Myers TE Iowa Stretch

 

DE Desmond Bryant, Harvard+

 

ILB Frantz Joseph, Florida Atlantic++ (fav longshot)

 

OG Jonathan Compas, UC-Davis+

 

 

San Diego Chargers: B-

 

OG: (good) Vasquez is an extremely nimble man for the amount he girth he can move around (332 lbs.)  He is also very strong, but must learn to use that strength in drive blocking  Greene is not quite as big or strong and certainly not as agile. McDonald is a hard-working big center who is smart enough (3.99 GPA) and big enough to play any position along the line, played in 48 college games.

RB: (average) Johnson is a low to the ground slasher who doesn't have great speed or agility.  There are also questions about his attitude and ability to be a team player.  May not fit well with L.T. and Sproles.  Brinkley is a similar stocky guy with a little more speed, but less power.  Rentmeester is a good blocker and a dedicated special teams warrior.

DE: (poor) It's possible English would try to gain 30 lbs to player here rather than the exemplary OLB he's projected to be.

ILB: (good) If his hip is healed, Felder should be an excellent pick-up.  He may need a bit more muscled to remain inside, but he's fast, strong and smart enough to play any LB.  Beckwith also isn't big and doesn't have Felder's speed or agility, but was rated an top 10 ILB early in the process before falling off the draft list altogether.  Holt is so small he might end up being a SS.  He has decent speed and excellent feet and was 3rd FBS forced fumbles.

DT: (good) Vaughn Martin is a real find from Canada.  Big, strong, fast, and extremely agile, he only needs experience and should only get better.  Jackson is a gamer, but he's not big, fast or agile. 

S: (average) Ellison may well have to play OLB at 230 he is not fast or agile enough to play S unless his anticipation and study compensates.  Spilman is a gifted athlete speed, decent feet, and a 42 in. vertical.  He has good hands, but needs to play more discplined. Hughes is very fast, smart and nimble, but is also weak, slight, and small.

Other: WR Byrd was called a smaller T.O. and now will also have to recover from an auto accident.  Carr is very tall (6-6), but not athletic or strong.  Martin, Chargers' VALUE pick as an UFA, has good size, plays wild, but has very good speed and hands, finishing his college career with 224 rec, 44 TDs, and was 7th Div II receptions.  TE Wurzbacher is a small school legend, a multi-year Great West 1st teamer who is tall, strong, and smart and was a steady contributor with key receptions, often downfield.  Speery, a similar player, is even faster, but needs even more bulk.  OT Allen was considered draftable, small school stud with size, speed and agility.  Muth is an all-Pac Ten selection with height, strength and grit.  K Sakoda was the top kicker on most boards though a couple others actually got drafted.  He was 4th FBS FG/G, .917 %, hit 2/3 +50.

Rd Pick Player Pos College
1 16 Larry English DE-OLB Northern Illinois
3 78 Louis Vasquez OG Texas Tech Can't Miss
4 113 Vaughn Martin DT Western Ontario
4 133 Tyronne Green OG Auburn reach
4 134 Gartrell Johnson RB Colorado State Reach
5 148 Brandon Hughes CB Oregon State
6 189 Kevin Ellison S USC Stretch
7 224 Demetrius Byrd WR LSU Stretch

OT Ben Muth, Stanford, San Diego

WR Greg Carr, Florida State

ILB Anthony Felder, Cal-Berkeley+

FB Bill Rentmeester, Wisconsin

FS C.J. Spillman, Marshall+

TE Jerimiah Wurzbacher, North Dakota State++ (fav longshot)

TE Kory Sperry, Colorado State+

OT Sam Allen, Grand Valley State++ (fav longshot)

OLB James Holt, Kansas

DT Rashaad Jackson, Clemson

RB Curtis Brinkley, Syracuse

ILB Darry Beckwith, L.S.U.+

C Ryan McDonald, Illinois++

WR Charly Martin, West Texas A&M++ (fav longshot)

PK Louis Sakoda, Utah++

 

 

Home